Friday, February 16, 2024
HomeEditor PickYoga Or Pilates For Lower Back Pain

Yoga Or Pilates For Lower Back Pain

A Brief History Of Pilates

Is Yoga Better Than Pilates For Back Pain?

Joseph Pilates, the founder of the epnoymous method, evolved his work from a background in bodybuilding, yoga, wrestling, boxing, gymnastics, and martial arts. Self-educated in anatomy, he became a nurse-physiotherapist during World War I, during which he rigged bedsprings to provide supported movement exercises to sick and injured people. This was an early model of the reformer machinea specialized piece of spring-driven Pilates equipmentthat we know today.

He called his method “contrology,” focusing mainly on the core, which he called the body’s “powerhouse.” If you’re familiar with both Pilates and yoga, you may have noticed some similarities between the two.

An example of a yoga posture that may have been adapted for Pilates is the elephant. Performed on the reformer, the move looks a lot like Downward Facing Dog in yoga but can feel quite different while you are performing it. Because the movement of the lower extremity is involved, the elephant is great for releasing low back muscle tension, increasing awareness of hip joints as well as the shoulder girdle. It also works the core muscles.

While strengthening the core is one of a number of benefits in yoga, it’s the primary intention in Pilates. Both systems will likely increase flexibility, strength, balance, and coordination both can be helpful in reducing or preventing back or neck pain.

So Which Is Best For People With Lower Back Pain

Pilates is widely believed to have advantages over yoga when it comes to lower back pain. This is because yoga often includes deeper backbends which can aggravate lower back pain. Although pilates also focuses on flexibility, its movements are typically less intense and are coupled with many more core strengthening exercises. These smaller, more stabilising movements help to build up key muscle groups, which can ultimately offer better protection for your spine.

However, the decision between yoga and pilates really boils down to personal preference and your teacher. While yoga can include deep backbends and more extreme postures , the right teacher will not allow you to undertake postures which are not suitable for your body. If you are able to find a good yoga teacher who understands your needs, the risks posed by yoga compared to pilates diminish radically.

Why Yoga Is Less Beneficial For Back Pain

Yoga on the other hand, again generally speaking at an amateur level, the consensus we receive from patients is that usually they will strive to achieve various yoga positions that can be unhealthy for a spine that is already compromised. These can include moves that involve backbends, the wheel, or bridge, and cobra. The end goal is often to be as flexible as possible, taking a joint to the complete end of its range.

If youre very flexible it does go some way to help decrease your likelihood of injury, but now you have a lot of lax, wobbly ligaments but no strength or integrity in your joints. Quite often with yoga, and this can be almost the same for any sport or activity, many people will tend to focus entirely on one activity rather than integrating cross-training. By combining your usual activity with any other form of exercise, youre really helping to create some variety in the muscles that are being worked in your body. If youre going all in for flexibility with yoga, its worthwhile combining this with gym-based work to also get some strengthening in your body too.

Don’t Miss: Power Yoga Calories Burned Calculator

There Are Still Controversies About The Effects Of Yoga At Different Follow

A September 2020 analysis of published research built on this theme of why yoga did not help some patients. Publishing in the journal Public Library of Science One, researchers gave this analysis of the benefits of yoga and why some do not get the benefits. Here are the learning points of this analysis:

  • Chronic low back pain is a common and often disabling musculoskeletal condition. Yoga has been proven to be an effective therapy for chronic low back pain. However, there are still controversies about the effects of yoga at different follow-up periods and compared with other physical therapy exercises.
  • This study evaluated the effects of yoga for patients with chronic low back pain on pain, disability, and quality of life.
  • Findings:
  • Yoga could significantly reduce pain at 4 to 8 weeks, 3 months, 6 to 7 months and was not significant in 12 months compared with non-exercise.
  • Yoga was better than non-exercise on disability at 4 to 8 weeks, 3 months, 6 months, 12 months.
  • There was no significant difference on pain, disability compared with the physical therapy exercise group. Furthermore, it suggested that there was a non-significant difference in physical and mental quality of life between yoga and any other interventions.

Pilates Exercise And Back Pain

Pilates for Lower Back Pain Relief

The important principles of Pilates are consistent with an exercise program that promotes back health. In particular, learning awareness of neutral alignment of the spine and strengthening the deep postural muscles that support this alignment are important skills for the back pain patient.

Patients with pain stemming from excessive movement and degeneration of the intervertebral discs and joints are particularly likely to benefit from a Pilates exercise program. In addition, postural asymmetries can be improved, thus decreasing wear and tear resulting from uneven stresses on the intervertebral joints and discs.

Pilates improves strength, flexibility, and suppleness of the muscles of the hip and shoulder girdle. Fluid and supported movement through these joints helps prevent unnecessary torque on the vertebral column.

The Pilates program also teaches awareness of movement habits that may stress the spine, and helps the patient change these habits to those that preserve neutral alignment. Awareness of excessive tension and the use of proper focus helps the patient use the body efficiently.

Don’t Miss: Yoga Ball Sizing

Does Pilates Or Yoga Help Low Back Pain

Like this article? Share the love!

Does Pilates or Yoga Help Low Back Pain?

I want to start yoga or pilates to help with my back pain

This is a common comment of back pain suffers at their initial physiotherapy assessment.

But is Pilates or yoga actually helpful in treating or preventing low back pain?

I normally advise that Pilates or yoga is great as a form of exercise. But do not choose to do it to solely cure your low back pain.

Pilates and yoga are excellent ways to improve general tone and fitness. However, its effectiveness as a treatment of low back pain is not proven.

To recover from low back pain and most muscle and joint injuries, your rehabilitation programme must include:

  • Movement correction: identify poor movement patterns and correct accordingly
  • Functional exercises: that are tailored to suit your goals
  • Load: Enough weight that challenges the muscles to get bigger and stronger
  • In Pilates or yoga, these components are not provided in sufficient amounts to gain appropriate back strength to prevent reinjury. In addition to this, in a class format of yoga and Pilates it is difficult to provide individualised exercises to help manage your lower back. What is good for your friends back on the mat next to you, may not be suitable for your back.

    Current research suggests that yoga and Pilates is a great way of gaining global flexibility and improving postural control. However, Pilates and yoga alone is in not enough to fortify your back against injury.

    Exercise Your Core Is Yoga Or Pilates Best For Lower Back Pain

    The muscles in your abdominal muscles and also back play an essential duty in sustaining your lower back. These muscular tissues dont obtain an excellent workout during the course of a regular day they need to be particularly targeted through exercise.

    There are numerous simple workouts that can be carried out in 20 to half an hour as part of your everyday regimen. If you are simply beginning, also the simple act of resting upright on an exercise ball for thirty minutes a day will engage your core muscles.

    You May Like: Yoga Studio Floor

    But Pilates Is More Than Just A Physical Workout

    Its six basic principlescentering, concentration, control, precision, breathing, and flowmay focus on the physical aspect of Pilates, but continued practice can also boost mental well-being. By learning to focus on your breathing, you center yourself and become more aware of your body. This meditative quality to Pilates lends itself to reducing factors that exacerbate pain like stress and anxiety.

    Further studies have also shown that expert meditators have a thicker cortex that is associated with lower pain sensitivity. So long-term practice of mindful meditation may then lead to enhancing parts of the brain that directly affect pain perception.

    The combination of positive physical and mental responses to Pilates is a big part of why many rehabilitation centers have incorporated it into their programs. Its an exercise truly anybody can do, says Kiser Schemper. Its very accessible to all fitness levels and easy to make it more or less challenging.

    With its stickability factor, Pilates makes it easy to alleviate back pain, as well as prevent new injuries from developing.

    Get more exercises to strengthen your back with 10-Minute Pilates from Prevention.

    Support from readers like you helps us do our best work. Go here to subscribe to Prevention and get 12 FREE gifts. And sign up for our FREE newsletter here for daily health, nutrition, and fitness advice.

    Pilates Vs Yoga: The Benefits Of Strength Training For Back Pain


    One of the best ways to reduce or prevent back pain is to exercise. But not just any exercise. You need an exercise that not only relaxes your spine and back muscles but also strengthens them.

    Two types of exercise that fit the bill are yoga and Pilates. Both are essential for healthy back care management. But which is better for long-term back pain relief?

    In certain ways, yoga and Pilates are alike, and in other ways, they are different. Yoga is focused directly on relaxing your body and mind and relieving it of stress and tension by using breathing, positions, and exercises. It is based on a series of movements, whose purpose is to stretch and strengthen your entire body. The breathing is slow, deep and rhythmical. Together, this fusion of the mind, body, and spirit is aimed at creating positive energy and spiritual well-being.

    Pilates also involves a mind, body and spirit approach in which you focus your awareness to your center or midsection and begin your specific movement sequences there, addressing each body part with your full concentration. Your breathing which is performed in a gentle, flowing manner is integrated with each exercise, with each part of a movement associated with inhaling and exhaling to enhance the connection between mind and body.

    Read Also: Lululemon Yoga Mat Care

    Yoga Can Be Best Effective When The Spinal Ligaments Are Strong If Spinal Instability Is The Problem Yoga Will Not Be Successful For Very Many Patients

    January 2017, a study lead by the University of Maryland published in The Cochrane Database of Systematic Reviews.

    The authors concluded:

    • There is low- to moderate-certainty evidence that yoga compared to non-exercise controls results in small to moderate improvements in back-related function at three and six months. .
    • Yoga may also be slightly more effective for pain at three and six months, however, the effect size did not meet predefined levels of minimum clinical importance. (Confirming again if spinal instability is the problem, yoga will not be successful for very many patients.
    • It is uncertain whether there is any difference between yoga and other exercises for back-related function or pain, or whether yoga added to exercise is more effective than exercise alone. .
    • Yoga is associated with more adverse events than non-exercise controls, but may have the same risk of adverse events as other back-focused exercises. .

    Pilates Works When There Are Strong Ligaments Pilates Will Not Help When Ligament Instability Prevents Muscles From Getting Needed Resistance

    Pilates is an exercise program that concentrates on the deep stabilizer muscles of the core. Pilates, like physical therapy, like core stabilizing exercises, can only work when the ligaments of the spine can support the exercise activity and provide resistance so the muscles strengthen.

    It is very rare to see research that says one form of exercise works and another does not. They either all work or they all dont work. Studies supporting one form of exercise over another support this idea.

    Here is the last paragraph from an August 2017 study in the Journal of Exercise Rehabilitation:

    On the basis of the present study it can be concluded that lumbar stabilization exercise, dynamic strengthening exercise, and Pilates are beneficial in the treatment of chronic nonspecific low back pain for reduction of pain, improvement in functional ability, increase range of motion and improve core strength.

    However, when compared, lumbar stabilization proved to be a more effective form of exercise than Pilates and dynamic strengthening for chronic low back pain.

    They all worked. One a little better than the others in this one group.

    Also Check: Do You Need To Be Certified To Teach Yoga

    Video: Pilates For Chronic Back Pain

    This video demonstrates pilates exercises that are suitable for those with chronic back pain.

    This exercise video is suitable for most people, but is not tailored to any specific condition, characteristic or person.

    Get advice from a GP or health professional before trying it, especially if:

    • you have any concerns about your health
    • you are not sure if the exercises are suitable
    • you have any pre-existing health problems or injuries, or any current symptoms

    Stop the exercise immediately and get medical help if you feel any pain or feel unwell.

    The Research On Yoga For Back Pain

    Pilates Exercises For Lower Back Pain

    For yoga, the picture research paints is a little brighter. A 2015 review published in the International Journal of Yoga looked at six studies involving 570 patients. The researchers found that in the short term, Iyengar may be effective for treating chronic spinal pain. The review, however, did not find evidence for yoga as a back treatment in the long term.

    Similarly, a 2013 study published in the Clinical Journal of Pain found strong evidence that yoga is effective in the short term. It also found moderate evidence for long-term use. The researchers recommend yoga as an “additional therapy for low-back pain.”

    And finally, the Oklahoma Medical Association weighed in on yoga and meditation in their 2017 meta-analysis. The review found that for people with osteoarthritis, rheumatoid arthritis, and low back pain, yoga and meditation significantly helped decrease pain and dysfunction.

    Read Also: How To Use A Exercise Ball To Induce Labor

    Is Pilates Good For You

    In a bid to take care of their back and/or neck pain, many people are prescribed Pilates and other lifestyle exercises like Yoga. Pilates is a great way to regain strength if you have back injuries or muscular imbalance. Whether or not Pilates is good for you depends very much on whether it is prescribed and performed appropriately. The problem does not lie with the exercise, but rather on the understanding of what it can help with and what it cannot.

    Pilates, Yoga and Tai Chi are all great exercises to help maintain a healthy spine. The keywords here are maintain and healthy. If you have a back problem or neck strain, you are advised against these exercises. Instead, you should be looking to fix your back, not maintain it. However, would doing these exercises a notch below the regular intensity help?

    According to Sylvia Ho, Principal Physiotherapist with Core Concepts, We often recommend our clients take up some form of exercise, including Yoga and Pilates. But not before they are ready. Back and neck pains are complex problems. Just because they are quite common doesnt mean that they are simple or all have the same underlying cause.

    Core Concepts Core Stability Programme further breaks down the initial stages of training to include sessions with Real-Time Ultrasound Imaging . Sylvia explains, With RTUI, our clients can get a better grasp of the fundamentals before progressing onto the group classes.

    The Benefits Of Yoga And Pilates For Lower Back Pain

    Home 0

    WITH the colder weather creeping in, Osteo and Physio are helping more clients who are complaining of aches and pains, particularly in the lower back.

    There has been talking in the news recently about how yoga and pilates can make a positive difference to lower back pain alleviating pain and improving ease of movement.

    Jonathan Boxall, the osteopath, said: As an osteopath, I regularly recommend yoga and pilates to clients, relating to posture and particularly lower back pain. They are both fantastic forms of exercise to support osteopathy treatment.

    • He said the main reasons yoga and pilates benefit people with back issues are:
    • They are excellent for core stability. A stronger core supports and takes the strain from your lower
    • They are great for balance which makes you less prone to injuries through jarring.
    • They are great for relaxation, which in turn reduces stress created by tight muscles.
    • They are a fitness activity that people enjoy and engage with.

    So if you find that you are suffering from lower back pain this winter, try Yoga to relieve the aches and pains.

    Osteo and Physio are here to help relieve your lower back pain. To book an appointment, visit the website at or telephone 01884 308123

    Don’t Miss: Dizziness After Yoga

    Just Walking May Be Better Than Yoga

    In August 2020, doctors writing in the medical journal Medicine compared walking and mind-body therapies, including yoga, which they note are commonly recommended to relieve pain and improve function in patients with chronic low back pain. What they found was that yoga, seemed to be more effective in the short term, and walking seems to be more effective in the intermediate term, for the relief of pain and activity limitation in patients with chronic low back pain.

    Medicine From The Shop Is Yoga Or Pilates Best For Lower Back Pain

    yoga for lower back pain

    There are 2 kinds of over the counter painkiller that often help with back pain: nonsteroidal anti-inflammatory medicines and acetaminophen. Both have some side effects, and also some people might not be able to take them. Speak to your medical professional prior to taking pain relievers And also dont expect medication alone to address your discomfort trouble. Researches reveal youll most likely require greater than one sort of treatment.

    Read Also: Hot Yoga Calories Calculator


    Popular Articles